Friday, June 2, 2023
My Account
Join Council
USA Wire
  • News
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • World
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Finance
    • Marketing
  • Culture
    • Lifestyle
    • Celebrity
    • Travel
  • Entertainment
    • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Health
    • Food
    • Fitness
  • Crypto
  • Technology
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • World
  • Business
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Finance
    • Marketing
  • Culture
    • Lifestyle
    • Celebrity
    • Travel
  • Entertainment
    • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Health
    • Food
    • Fitness
  • Crypto
  • Technology
No Result
View All Result
USA Wire
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Dawkins makes a “big admission” in Collins debate… but not the one you’re thinking of!

USA Wire Staff<span class="bp-verified-badge"></span> by USA Wire Staff
August 5, 2022
in Opinion
Reading Time: 5 mins read
Dawkins makes a “big admission” in Collins debate… but not the one you’re thinking of!
11
SHARES
81
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I owe Prof Richard Dawkins plenty of thanks because his book The God Delusion and the ensuing debates provoked me to explore the question of evidence for God’s existence, which eventually brought me to Christian belief. I was used to the militant, sometimes incandescent Dawkins, often describing religious faith as a “virus” while pitting himself against sometimes equally antagonistic religious opponents.

A Less Militant Dawkins

Yet his recent dialogue with Dr. Francis Collins on Premier Unbelievable?’s The Big Conversation was a breath of fresh air and an inspiring departure from that combative mode of interaction. It’s clear that these two gentlemen, while holding completely opposite views about God, have profound respect for each other (the only references to viruses here came when both scientists reveled in discussing genetics and the causes of the COVID19 pandemic).

RecommendedReads

Empowering youth: Terri Banner Fitzsimmons on helping young people thrive

5 Negotiation Tips for Gen Z

Doug Patton on Inspirations of Creativity Exclusive Interview

Because of this warm and genuine rapport, I think Dawkins opened up and made some of his most remarkable admissions and concessions to date – in a way that would not have happened had his back been against the wall.

I am not referring, however, to Dawkins’ remarks that “you could possibly persuade me to become a deist” and that “if somebody were to convince me of the need for a God, it would be there” (referring to the Argument from Design based on the “fine-tuning” of the universe’s fundamental physical constants). As Dawkins pointed out, those types of comments have been sensationalized and taken out of context. While Dawkins referred to fine-tuning as “a good argument,” he made it clear that he still has a major roadblock to accepting it and thus is not a convert (he was even able to joke about this with Collins).

Admitting to Presuppositions

Rather, I am referring to an admission by Dawkins concerning that roadblock itself. This was not a “gotcha” rather it was freely offered in a commendable moment of self-reflection (which, once again, I attribute to Dawkins’ feeling at ease in the conversation with Collins).  When asked whether he’d be dissatisfied with a non-physical explanation for the universe, Dawkins replied:

 “That’s part of it. I suppose perhaps we both come at it with … a bit of presupposition. As somebody who’s deeply steeped in evolution, I am kind of in love with the idea that it’s possible to explain complex things in terms of simple things.” 

This was something I had not seen before. Dawkins was ready to acknowledge that he may be approaching the question of God’s existence with materialistic (or naturalistic) preferences (indeed, the very word he used, “presupposition,” is striking because Christian apologists most commonly use it)!

Not only did he readily open himself up to considering the possibility that he has materialistic, and specifically Darwinian, presuppositions against God, but Dawkins agreed with Collins that God if he exists, “must be” a mind.

One wonders, therefore, where Dawkins stands now regarding his roadblock to accepting the fine-tuning argument. He has conceded that God would have to be a mind, which, as many of Dawkins’ critics have pointed out, is an immaterial entity. This would entail that God is ultimately simple in structure (unlike the material universe), which would undercut Dawkins’ central atheistic objection: that God must be “complex.” This objection depends upon the very naturalistic presuppositions that Dawkins has admitted to.

Miracles Remain a Stumbling Block

But perhaps most noteworthy is how this affects how Dawkins interacts with the case for the Resurrection of Jesus. Throughout the conversation, Dawkins expressed incredulity at the idea that God would perform miracles, calling Collins out for his “unscientific” view in this area, to which Collins responded: 

“You must see that you’re applying your own view, that anything that can’t be explained naturally must be an intellectual error. And you and I are different in that regard. I’m allowing the possibility of the supernatural – a Creator God who’s responsible for everything.”

As Collins pointed out, Dawkins’ presuppositions have rigged the outcome. If the material universe is a closed system, and miracles by definition cannot happen in the first place, then no amount of evidence for miracles will ever be acceptable (even if, as Dawkins himself helpfully reminded us, a spate of them happened “between 0AD and 30AD” – anno Domini meaning “in the year of our Lord”)!

One cannot help but wonder what Dawkins would make of NT Wright’s book The Resurrection of the Son of God, which Collins recommended to him during this conversation. I suspect that, given the rapport between these two gentlemen, despite their differences, the fact that this recommendation came from Collins might mean that Dawkins has the most likelihood of giving it a chance!

That’s why I think Dawkins’ willingness to reflect upon the role of presuppositions was his biggest admission in this terrific exchange, aided by his respect for Collins.

The Questions We Should Be Asking

In short, tabloid headlines along the lines of “is Richard Dawkins converting?” do not ask the right questions.

What we really need to be asking is:

To what extent are all of us (including Richard Dawkins) prepared to question our most fundamental assumptions, and what are we doing to create the kinds of environments and relationships that most encourage this to happen? Are we willing to engage in dialogue with those with whom we might disagree to better understand their arguments and defend our beliefs?

I believe that The Big Conversation is a big step in the right direction! Our reasoning and arguments can only be strengthened by hearing the top thinkers in their field discuss their beliefs about life, faith, and meaning. 

Peter Byrom is an administrator with Premier and is contributing his conversion story to a collection of essays entitled Coming to Faith Through Dawkins – publishing soon by Kregel Publications, by 12 authors from five countries explaining how the New Atheists played important roles in their pathways to Christian faith.

By Peter Byrom

Tags: DawkinsdebateevidenceexistenceGod
Share4Tweet3
Previous Post

Valentin Luboya -The Author of The Book ‘The Wealth 2021’

Next Post

Why Companies Such as X1 Esports Need to Target This Key Demographic

USA Wire Staff<span class="bp-verified-badge"></span>

USA Wire Staff

USA Wire is a millennial-focused news publication that provides content in a way that relates to the modern world. USA Wire strives to provide unbiased and accurate coverage of current events, highlighting both the good and bad.

Related Posts

edit post
Inspirations of Creativity
Opinion

Doug Patton on Inspirations of Creativity Exclusive Interview

May 19, 2023
edit post
Have It All
Opinion

Interview: USA Wire speaks to Paul Mayson after the release of his latest single ‘Have It All’

May 13, 2023
edit post
Adversity
Opinion

4 Surprisingly Good Reasons to Embrace Adversity in Your Life

May 13, 2023
Next Post
edit post
Why Companies Such as X1 Esports Need to Target This Key Demographic

Why Companies Such as X1 Esports Need to Target This Key Demographic

edit post
“ Martin Huu Nguyen ''  Drops  official  Music Playlist  '' Is It Real ''

“Martin Huu Nguyen'' Drops Official Music Playlist ''Is It Real''

edit post
Rihanna-f79e87ae

Rihanna is Now Worth $1.4 Billion–making Her America’s Youngest Self-made Billionaire Woman

Discussion about this post

Follow us

Recommended

edit post

20s Are Too Early to Double Down on a Career- Eyal Danon

1 year ago
edit post
Untitled design-8d30f315

Board-Certified Geriatric Pharmacist, Kobi Nathan, Empowers Older Adults to Identify and Reduce Overmedication and Adverse Drug Reactions

1 year ago
edit post
Crowdfunding

6 Reasons Every Investor Should Consider Crowdfunding

6 months ago
edit post
Wlodzimierz

Wlodzimierz Pietraszko: Bonsai Art’s Global Legacy

2 weeks ago

Categories

  • Business
  • Celebrity
  • Construction
  • Crypto
  • Culture
  • Electrical
  • Entertainment
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Finance
  • Fitness
  • Food
  • Gaming
  • Health
  • Home Improvement
  • Lifestyle
  • Marketing
  • Medicine
  • Movies
  • Music
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Plumbing
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • World

Topics

2018 FIFA World Cup (9) 2018 League (12) Alcatraz East (8) America (10) Asian Games 2018 (17) Balinese Culture (10) Bali United (9) book (8) Budget Travel (17) Business (17) celebrity (15) Chopper Bike (11) clothing (8) dadsrc (9) Digital (8) Entrepreneur (10) family (9) fitness (11) food (11) fun (11) future (10) Health (29) healthcare (8) home (16) Idenfy (9) impact (8) Istana Negara (17) life (9) Market Stories (22) museum (8) music (11) National Exam (13) New (9) nightclub (9) pandemic (11) partnership (10) Paws of War (13) performance (10) podcast (11) summer (14) technology (8) therapy (7) tips (16) Visit Bali (16) WonderWorks (19)
USA Wire

© 2021 USA Wire

Navigate Site

  • Join Council – Become a Contributor
  • Contact
  • My Account

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Join Council
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel

© 2021 USA Wire

Go to mobile version