Few decisions about bathroom renovation affect its look, layout, or budget in quite the same way as whether to place a shower in a tub. It might well define how your bathroom will function and even look for many years to come. Consider the luxury of either the convenience of a steamy shower or the pure comfort offered by a bath. Knowing the differences, advantages, and disadvantages can help solve many questions and ease the decision when faced with this choice for your home. Let us closely consider these shower-and-bathtub questions to attend fully and adequately to what would serve your remodel best, using the same help—Volcano Builders.
Differences Between Showers and Bathtubs
Showers and bathtubs serve the same primary purpose—cleaning the body—but they offer distinct experiences and have unique features.
Showers:
● Functionality: Showers offer quick and efficient cleansing in a continuous water flow from an overhead spray.
● Styles: Shower stalls come in either an enclosed design with a door and curtain or walk-in designs with no doors or curtains; they can be in a very minimal, modern style or a traditional one.
● Materials: Materials commonly used in showers include fiberglass, acrylic, tile, and high-end natural stone. This way, there is a wide range of choices regarding aesthetics and budgeting.
● Therapeutic Options: Showers can be equipped with rainfall or waterfall showerheads to provide a tranquil experience, and multi-head showers and body sprays can be so refreshing, almost spa-like.
Bathtubs:
● Functionality: A bathtub is a basin filled with water for those who want to soak and cleanse themselves. Bathtubs are designed for long, indulgent baths.
● Styles: Tubs can be a standard alcove, stylish and classy claw-foot, freestanding, deeper soaking, whirlpool with inherent jets, or walk-in for easy access.
● Materials: Bathtubs come in many materials, from inexpensive acrylic and fiberglass to highly finished enamel-coated cast iron, all the way up to indulgent copper or stone.
● Medical Options: Whirlpool tubs are equipped with jets in the bottom of the tub that spasmodically shoot out blasts of massage-type water, which assist in muscle relaxation and recovery.
Pros and Cons of Showers
Pros:
1. Space-Saving Design: Showers typically take up less floor space than bathtubs, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms. A standard shower stall or walk-in shower occupies about 9 square feet on average.
2. Accessibility: Showers are easier to access, especially for the elderly or those with mobility issues, thanks to options like walk-in and curbless designs. Features such as grab bars and benches enhance safety and convenience.
3. Water Efficiency: Showers generally use less water than baths, especially with low-flow showerheads. An eight-minute shower with a low-flow showerhead uses about 17 gallons of water, compared to a bathtub that uses 25-40 gallons.
4. DIY-Friendly Installation: Prefabricated shower stalls and kits are available for homeowners with basic plumbing skills, making installation simpler and more cost-effective.
Cons:
1. Limited Relaxation Options: Showers do not provide the same level of relaxation as soaking in a bathtub. The experience is more about quick and efficient cleansing.
2. Resale Value Considerations: Homes without bathtubs may be less appealing to families with young children, potentially impacting resale value. Some homebuyers see a full bathroom as one that includes a tub.
Pros and Cons of Bathtubs
Pros:
1. Ideal for Relaxation: Bathtubs are perfect for soaking and relaxing, offering a spa-like experience at home. They can help relieve stress and soothe sore muscles.
2. Family-Friendly: Bathtubs are easier for bathing young children and can be more convenient for elderly family members when designed with safety features like grab bars and non-slip surfaces.
3. High Resale Value: Bathtubs are often preferred by homebuyers, especially families. According to a National Association of Home Builders survey, 51% of home buyers prefer a master bathroom with a tub, which can enhance resale value.
Cons:
1. Space Requirements: Bathtubs require more floor space, which can be challenging in smaller bathrooms. A standard bathtub occupies about 13 square feet.
2. Higher Water Usage: Filling a bathtub uses significantly more water compared to a quick shower, impacting water bills. Whirlpool tubs can use up to 80-100 gallons per use.
3. Installation and Maintenance Costs: Bathtubs can be more expensive to install and maintain, especially high-end models like whirlpool tubs. They also require professional installation to avoid issues such as leaks and improper setup.
Key Considerations for Your Decision
When selecting what to include between a shower and a bathtub for your bathroom remodel, several factors should influence the decision.
Space: Look at how big your bathroom is as well as all the fixtures that you have within it. Smaller areas work best for showers, but bathtubs require a different amount of space altogether. Consider how each option will impact your space and the functionality of it altogether.
Lifestyle Needs: Think about your day-to-day routine and what you prefer. Showers are quick, efficient, and a great way to get going in the morning. Bathtubs offer the luxury of a relaxing retreat at the end of a long day. Consider who will be using the bathroom and what their requirements will be.
Budget: Compare installation and material costs with maintenance. Showers can be more budget-friendly, while a bathtub may give more excellent long-term value and satisfaction. Consider the possible need for professional installation with both options.
Resale Value: Think ahead to the future homeowners. Most families prefer one bathtub, and not having one may lessen your home’s attractiveness on the market. Sleek, luxurious showers are an excellent option in addition to the tub, especially in the master bath.
Benefits of a Shower-Tub Combo
A shower and tub combination is the perfect in-between, but, more often than not, you may be torn between the benefits of a shower and a bathtub for your bathroom remodeling project.
Versatility: This is where you can enjoy the convenience of a shower and the luxury of a bathtub; the best option for switching between quick showers and relaxing soaks.
Space Efficiency: It maximizes the available space in bathrooms, especially the smaller ones, for that quick shower and a relaxing soak with efficiency—enjoying the best of both worlds without having to install separate fixtures.
Family-Oriented: This accommodation will perfectly suit family members who are either senior citizens or early childhood individuals by providing an easy and safe method for bathing. Easy entry, comfort, and safety are all assured by the shower-tub combination for everyone.
Resale Appeal: Many people view having a shower-tub combo as offering greater potent appeal when reselling a home due to the wide variety of potential buyers to whom it can appeal. It shows flexibility and value for money, catering to different lifestyle needs.
Why Waterproof Panels are a Must-Have for Your Bathroom Walls(Opens in a new browser tab)
Conclusion
One of the vital decisions one has to make when redoing a bathroom is between a shower and a bathtub. This depends on personal needs, space constraints, budget, and plans for the future. Where showers save space, are accessible, and offer better water efficiency, bathtubs provide relaxation time, family-friendliness, and resale value. Or, if you just can’t decide, consider a shower-tub combo for the best of both worlds.
For all professional advice and premium quality regarding bathroom remodels, trust Volcano Builders for the ideal bathroom for living your lifestyle. Contact us today, and let us help you through the process of building your dream bathroom design. From great walk-in showers perfect for lounging to whirlpool tubs where all stress fades away, our experienced team will walk you through every process.
